In times of increasing public depression due to the various effects of the Covid-19 epidemic, the public was again confronted with threats to the right to speech in public. The trigger was none other than the policy of the Indonesian National Police Chief who is currently held by Commissioner General Idham Azis to issue a Telegram Letter numbered ST / 1100 / IV / HUK.7.1 / 2020 on April 4, 2020.
The telegram letter regarding the handling of the case and guidelines for carrying out the tasks during the period of preventing the spread of Covid-19. There are two points each containing five and seven subpoints. In point 1C contains the rules regarding the form of violation of "insult" to the President and Government Officials in the context of the handling of Covid-19 conducted by the Government.
Seeing this condition, it seems that there is coercion in its implementation, and opens the risk of abuse of power by law enforcement if input or criticism is considered an insult to the President and State Officials. So that people will be increasingly afraid to provide input or criticism to the Government regarding the handling of the Covid 19 outbreak, lest criticism by the public is interpreted as "insulting".
The Telegram letter also has the potential to trigger violations of freedom of speech in public, which is explicitly regulated in Law 9 of 1998 on Freedom of Expressing Opinion in Public. In addition, according to the provisions of Article 28 of the 1945 Constitution, restrictions on human rights can only be by law.
For cases of insult to the President and Government Officials, the National Police Chief must refer to Article 207 of the Criminal Code. In the Decision of the Constitutional Court (MK) si No. 013-022 / PUU-IV / 2006, the Constitutional Court in its consideration stated that related to the enactment of Article 207 of the Criminal Code, prosecution was only carried out on the basis of complaints from the authorities. So, if the insulted government does not complain this humiliation case, then it cannot be convicted. Thus it is clear that since the existence of this Constitutional Court ruling, the formulation of Article 207 offense has been changed from the usual offense to complaint offense. Because there has been a change in the type of offense, it can also be interpreted that the dignity referred to in this article has also undergone a change, namely only on the dignity of public officials / authorities as individuals, no longer the dignity of institutions (content fo personal and not content of institutional).
Through MK Decision No. 013-022 / PUU-IV / 2006 and the Constitutional Court's decision No. 6 / PPU-V / 2007 has also canceled a number of articles in the Criminal Code that target cases of insult to the President. Like Article 134, Article 136 bis, and Article 137 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Code. The criminalization of presidential insults is no longer relevant to be applied because in a democratic country all policies and actions of the president or government officials will always be criticized both constructive and destructive, especially now that we are in the transition period of colonial inheritance law.
If referring to the Constitutional Court's decision above, the article governing insults to the president and government officials is an unconstitutional article. Likewise to enact article 207 of the Criminal Code the president or state officials who feel offended by public criticism must report it as an individual.
Seeing current conditions, of course the government should focus more on preventing the expansion of the impact of the covid-19 virus, because what should be a priority is to save the community from all impacts caused by the pandemic rather than reporting the community for alleged humiliation.
With the existence of the ST National Police Chief, it shows that the condition of government officials is not being psychologically good, this makes the government condition to be sensitive to developing issues. As the executor of the task, the government should be ready to accept all input and criticism from the community as part of community supervision of the Government's performance, no matter how bitter it is.
The presence of this policy is also very contrary to the amnesty policy issued by the Ministry of Law and Human Rights through the Decree of the Minister of Law and Human Rights No. M.HH-19 PK.01.04.04 of 2020, the purpose of the assimilation issued by KEMENKUMHAM is to reduce the number of prisoners to anticipate the spread of the virus. Corona or Covid -19 in prison, this is inversely proportional to the policy issued by the National Police Chief through the Telegram Letter.
For this reason the Indonesian National Police Chief Commissioner General Idham Azis was asked to revoke the Telegram Letter as soon as possible and to focus on helping all elements in efforts to prevent and mitigate the effects of this national disaster.
By:
Marwan Fadhel Majid, S. H. I., M. H (Legal Practitioner)

Comments For This News (0)
Post a comment