By: Mulya Sarmono, S.H., M.H
The existence of a Single Candidate has become one of the discourses in the 2024 Simultaneous Regional Head Elections. Its emergence based on the decision of the Constitutional Court (MK) to uphold human rights, on its journey was "used" by the Oligarchy to easily gain political power. This indicates that the power of the Oligarchy, even after the reform, can still consolidate and influence democracy again, especially in the era of decentralization of regional power. According to Vedi R. Hadiz, the localization of power has actually provided opportunities for a number of New Order elites who, although temporarily, were threatened by the fall of the authoritarian regime, their patron. However, this has also provided a new opportunity for them to position themselves in response to new circumstances to survive and become dominant again.[1]
In reality, democracy and oligarchy under certain conditions do not negate each other, as stated by Winters that democracy refers to formal political power distributed based on the rights, procedures, and level of people's participation. Meanwhile, oligarchy is defined as concentrated material power based on the enforcement of claims or rights to property and wealth. The nature of political power that is expanded or narrowed as the system becomes more or less democratic is different from political power that can be materially dispersed or accumulated. That is why democracy and oligarchy can be compatible, as long as the two realms of power do not collide. In fact, democracy and oligarchy can live together continuously as long as the lower, propertyless classes do not use their wider political participation to seize the material power and privileges of the richest class.[2]
A concrete example of the statement above can be found in the election of Single Candidates in various regions against Empty Columns. Starting from the fulfillment of the right to be elected, the previous rules that did not accommodate the existence of single candidates were then realized by the Constitutional Court in order to maintain democracy so that it continues as it should and guarantees the constitutional rights of citizens.[3] The new channel then continues to accommodate each region to carry out its Pilkada according to schedule, even though it only consists of one pair of candidates. In 2015, from the Pilkada in 32 (thirty-two) provinces and 259 (two hundred and fifty-nine) regencies/cities, there were 3 (three) regions that only consisted of one pair of candidates, namely North Central Timor Regency (NTT), Blitar (East Java) and Tasikmalaya (West Java).[4] In 2017, the Regional Head Election will be held in 101 (one hundred and one) regions with details, 7 (seven) provinces, 18 (eighteen) cities and 76 (seventy-six) regencies.[5] The number of Single Candidates that year increased to 9 (nine) candidates. The areas are Tebing Tinggi, West Tulang Bawang, Pati, Buton, Landak, Central Maluku, Tambrauw, Sorong City and Jayapura.[6]
In 2018, the Pilkada was held in 171 (one hundred and seventy one) regions with details, at the provincial level totaling 17 (seventeen) regions, 39 (thirty nine) in the city area and elections in the district totaling 115 (one hundred and fifteen) regions. The regions that only consist of one pair of candidates total 16 (sixteen) regions consisting of Deli Serdang, Central Minahasa, North Padang Lawas, Enrekang, Prabumulih City, Makassar City, Pasuruan, Mamasa, Lebak, Central Mamberamo, Tangerang, Puncak, Tangerang City, Jayawijaya, Tapin and Bone.[7] In 2020, there are 270 (two hundred and seventy) electoral districts covering 9 (nine) provinces, 224 (two hundred and twenty four) districts and 37 (thirty seven) cities.[8] The number of Single Candidates is in 25 regions with details, Humbang Hasundutan, Gunung Sitoli City, Pematangsiantar City, Pasaman, Ogan Komering Ulu, South Ogan Komering Ulu, North Bengkulu, Boyolali, Grobogan, Kebumen, Semarang City, Sragen, Wonosobo, Kediri, Ngawi, Badung, West Sumbawa, Balikpapan City, Kutai Kartanegara, Gowa, Soppeng, Central Mamuju, South Manokwari, Arfak Mountains and Raja Ampat.[9]
The birth of the Single Candidate has divided and simplified society, namely between the Single Candidate and his various cronies, both political parties and oligarchs, with society in general outside of power. Similarly, Karl Marx and Engels analyzed the simplification of class in the modern bourgeois era by stating that the bourgeois era has simplified class conflicts. Society as a whole is increasingly divided into two large groups that directly confront each other - the bourgeoisie and the proletariat.[10]
As an oppressed class, the actor who can become an agent of change that can provide balancing power to the bourgeoisie, in order to free itself from exploitation according to Karl Marx and Engels, is the working class. Karl Marx and Engels stated that with the development of industry, the proletariat not only increases in number; it becomes concentrated in a larger mass, its power increases and it increasingly feels that power. The various interests and conditions of life in the ranks of the proletariat are becoming more and more equal, as all distinctions of labour are abolished by machinery and as wages are lowered almost everywhere to a uniform low level. The increasing competition among the bourgeoisie and the resulting commercial crises cause the wages of the workers to fluctuate continually. The incessant improvement of machinery is growing ever more rapidly, making their living more and more precarious; the clashes between the individual worker and the individual bourgeoisie are becoming more and more like clashes between two classes.[11]
(Continued..........)
1. Vedi R. Hadiz, Lokalisasi Kekuasaan di Indonesia Pascaotoritarianisme, (Jakarta: Kepustakaan Populer Gramedia, 2022), 225-226.
2. Jeffrey A. Winters, Oligarki, Terj. Zia Anshor, (Jakarta: PT. Gramedia Pustaka Utama, 2011), 16.
3. Selengkapnya, lihat Putusan MK RI No. 100/PUU-XIII/2015 tertanggal 28 September 2015.
4. Joko Panji Sasongko, Pilkada Tiga Daerah dengan Calon Tunggal Dinilai Lancar, (cnnindonesia.com), 10 Desember 2015, diakses pada 14 Agustus 2024. https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20151210133536-32-97294/pilkada-tiga-daerah-dengan-calon-tunggal-dinilai-lancar.
5. Bagus Prihantoro Nugroho, Ini Data 7 Provinsi, 18 Kota, dan 76 Kabupaten di Pilkada 2017, (detik.com), 13 Februari 2017, diakses pada 14 Agustus 2024. https://news.detik.com/berita/d-3421244/ini-data-7-provinsi-18-kota-dan-76-kabupaten-di-pilkada-2017/1.
6. Danang Firmanto, 9 Daerah ini Hanya Punya Calon Tunggal dalam Pilkada 2017, (tempo.co), 7 Februari 2017, diakses pada 14 Agustus 2024. https://pilkada.tempo.co/read/844005/9-daerah-ini-hanya-punya-calon-tunggal-dalam-pilkada-2017.
7. Muhammad Ridwan, Pilkada Serentak 2018: Ada 16 Calon Tunggal, Jumlah Paslon & Pemilih, (bisnis.com), 26 Juni 2018, diakses pada 14 Agustus 2024. https://kabar24.bisnis.com/read/20180626/15/809737/pilkada-serentak-2018-ada-16-calon-tunggal-jumlah-paslon-pemilih.
8. Nur Rohmi Aida dan Sari Hardiyanto, Berikut Daftar 270 Daerah yang Gelar Pilkada Serentak 9 Desember 2020, (kompas.com), 05 Desember 2020, diakses pada 14 Agustus 2024. https://www.kompas.com/tren/read/2020/12/05/193100165/berikut-daftar-270-daerah-yang-gelar-pilkada-serentak-9-desember-2020?page=all.
9. Ahmad Faiz Ibnu Sani, Ini 25 Calon Tunggal Kepala Daerah di Pilkada 2020, (tempo.co), 14 September 2020, diakses pada 14 Agustus 2024. https://pilkada.tempo.co/read/1386023/ini-25-calon-tunggal-kepala-daerah-di-pilkada-2020.
10. Karl Marx Frederick Engels, Manifesto Partai Komunis, (E-book pdf: ECONARCH Institute, 2009), 2. https://rowlandpasaribu.files.wordpress.com/2013/09/marx-engels-manifesto-partai-komunis.pdf.
11. Ibid., 12-13.

Comments For This News (0)
Post a comment